Heads up: Some or all of the identifications affected by this split may have been replaced with identifications of Fringilla. This happens when we can't automatically assign an identification to one of the output taxa. Review identifications of Fringilla coelebs 10070

Taxonomic Split 132801 (Committed on 15-12-2023)

DO NOT COMMIT - LARGE SPLIT NEEDS STAFF INPUT

Azores Chaffinch Fringilla moreletti, Madeira Chaffinch F. maderensis, Canary Islands Chaffinch F. canariensis, andAfrican Chaffinch F. spodiogenys are split from Common Chaffinch Fringilla coelebs (Clements 2007:625626)

Details: While all European forms (except the nominate) long treated as conspecific under Fringilla coelebs (Mayr 1968) were originally described as subspecies, all taxa from Macaronesian islands and northern Africa were described as full species. The complex has long been recognized for its marked polytypy and has been well-studied (summarized in Illera et al. 2016), including the considerable vocal disparity which however is of unclear significance for species limits in this complex due to vocal learning (e.g., Lachlan et al. 2013). Illera et al. (2016) proposed considering the taxa of each of the three main Macaronesian island groups as separate species, but this has not been widely followed. Shirihai and Svensson (2018) concluded based on unexpected results in early genetic analyses that all should be considered conspecific. However, the integrative taxonomic analysis of Recuerda et al. (2021) provided a solid framework in terms of morphological and genetic analysis that WGAC, Gill et al. (2023, IOC v.13.2), and Clements et al. (2023) agree strongly supports the recognition of five species, with the African forms being the weakest species candidate, despite the most obvious plumage differences.

eBird/Clements Checklist v2023 (Citation)
Added by rjq on 28 October, 2023 17:55 | Committed by loarie on 15 December, 2023
split into

Comments

@rjq should Fringilla coelebs sensu stricto atlas extend into North Africa or do those need to be turned off before committing?

Posted by loarie 7 months ago

@loarie the atlases are correct, coelebs s.s. is a winter visitor to North Africa, so the range overlaps that of spodiogenys. For example https://www.inaturalist.org/observations?place_id=7306&preferred_place_id=113055&taxon_id=236821.

Posted by rjq 7 months ago

great thanks - this is now committing records

Posted by loarie 7 months ago

The distribution maps need to be updated with the species split

Posted by donalddavesne 7 months ago

Add a Comment

Sign In or Sign Up to add comments