Heads up: Some or all of the identifications affected by this split may have been replaced with identifications of Spiraea. This happens when we can't automatically assign an identification to one of the output taxa. Review identifications of Spiraea betulifolia 84724

Taxonomic Split 129016 (Committed on 08-08-2023)

DO NOT COMMIT!!! READ NOTES:

POWO treats lucida as a full species; all western North America obs need to be transferred over. Unsure of what to do with eastern US and European obs. Will dig into it more.

Added by birdwhisperer on 05 August, 2023 05:57 | Committed by birdwhisperer on 08 August, 2023
split into

Comments

@kierandh @bouteloua This split is absolutely needed but might release some chaos, so anything to help will be appreciated.

Summary: Running a pre-split check, the change is definitely necessary since out of 7,149 identifications, 5,479 need to be transferred to S. lucida, and 342 to S. corymbosa. But I can't explain all the European or non-Appalachian eastern US reports, so that leaves us with 1207 ids that get bumped to genus if we commit. In the long run, it's better to have 1207 ids reelevated than have 5479 misapplied ids, but we should figure out how to shrink the former number.

Posted by birdwhisperer 11 months ago

@birdwhisperer Unfortunately, I can't speak definitively to anything beyond the S. betulifolia in northwestern North America that should become S. lucida. I think some of the non-Appalachian eastern US reports are indeed other species of Spiraea, like S. japonica, which is common in cultivation, but obviously I haven't checked every single one. Many of the ones I did check are very clearly not even Spiraea. I think it is fine to bump them to genus. Thank you for your help with this complex split.

Posted by kierandh 11 months ago

@birdwhisperer I think we are good to commit this change. If you have reservations about elevating too many observations to genus level, is there a way to leave them at the species level?

Posted by kierandh 11 months ago

Add a Comment

Sign In or Sign Up to add comments