Suggesting a New Feature for iNaturalist

During my time using iNaturalist this weekend, I had a thought about a feature that I believe would be helpful to the users of the app. Often times, the iNaturalist community is very helpful in identifying plant species that the uploading user is unfamiliar with and can describe but cannot readily identify. Last week during class, someone asked if there was a way to request identification - essentially asking "is there a way to put an observation out there and increase viewing traffic in hopes of someone seeing it who can then identify it?" Flavio mentioned that it is important to be as detailed as possible when uploading and describing an observation - that identifying a species on any level, even in a very broad sense, as opposed to just writing "unknown species" is the best way to hope that it will be identified. I recall, in the past, using field ID guides or even identification apps that basically guide you through identifying a species of interest - tools that ask a series of simple, almost yes or not questions, to help narrow down the possibilities of what it might be. What group does this plant belong to - woody plants, aquatic plants, grass-like plants? Does this plant have broad leaves or needle-like leaves? I wonder if having a series of description-related questions associated with each observation, whether or not the app is eventually able to suggest an identification or not, would be beneficial to the user. At least this way there would be a basic level of information and features already confirmed about the species. iNaturalist could give a narrowed-down suggestion of IDs based on the questions the user has answered, or at least when other users attempt to help identify the species they will have a basis of knowledge to work from. I am not sure exactly what the best way to implement this new feature would be, but I think there could be some very user-friendly ways to do so. Let me know what you guys think!

Posted on 10 May, 2020 15:19 by jearn043 jearn043

Comments

I think it is an interesting idea, but may take a lot of human input to get it correct (many many hours), as well as software development.

What folks often do is upload good photos of plants, use the computer vision algorithm to get closer, then tag a top identifier to help.

The guide you speak of that helps you determine better which taxa a plant (or any life) falls into is called a dichotomous taxonomic key. A key leads you through a set of choices to hopefully get you to an identification. Many keys have a learning curve because to save space, they use glossary terms you need to learn. A really good key will have an entire section with line drawings and glossary terms to help the user understand the definitions. When first learning a key, a lot of flipping over to the glossary and drawings will take place.

Now many keys are hosted online, and will walk you through this process.

Here is simple general one for Botany:

https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/simple/

Posted by leafybye about 4 years ago

It is worth checking out Flora from the library or finding one online for your local area, state, region, etc. If in California, I start here: https://ucjeps.berkeley.edu/IJM_keys/IJM_fam_key.html

Posted by leafybye about 4 years ago

I agree with leafybye.And I think this would be a great feature

Posted by jobird about 4 years ago

By the way, you can make feature requests in the iNaturalist forum, in the feature request area.

https://forum.inaturalist.org/

Posted by leafybye about 4 years ago

Add a Comment

Sign In or Sign Up to add comments